OncethenBuild my plan

Free lesson · The Renaissance · 6 min

The Impossible Dome

Florence's great cathedral had a giant hole where its dome should be, and nobody knew how to close it. Then a goldsmith named Filippo Brunelleschi said he could.

The story

A hole in the roof

It is 1418, in Florence, in Italy. The city's great cathedral has been under construction for more than a hundred years. Its walls are finished, and the eight-sided base for a dome rises high above the streets. But where the dome should be, there is only sky: a gap more than 40 metres wide. No one has built a dome this big since the days of ancient Rome, and nobody knows how to do it. So the cathedral's builders announce a competition. Whoever can solve the problem will win a prize.

Why it mattered

An age of rebirth

By about 1400, Italian cities like Florence had grown rich from trade, banking and the cloth industry. Their scholars and artists became fascinated by the writings, buildings and art of ancient Greece and Rome, and tried to equal or beat them. Historians call this period the Renaissance, from a French word meaning rebirth. That name became popular in the 1800s, but the idea is older: in 1550 the writer Giorgio Vasari already spoke of a rebirth of the arts. Florence's cathedral dome would become one of the first great symbols of this new age.

Why it mattered

The goldsmith's plan

Filippo Brunelleschi was born in Florence in 1377 and trained as a goldsmith. According to an early biography, he had also gone to Rome to study its ancient ruins. Normally, builders supported a dome with a huge wooden frame while the stones were laid. But a frame wide enough for this gap would have needed more timber than anyone could find. Brunelleschi claimed he could build the dome with no frame at all, rising ring by ring until it held itself up. The competition dragged on for two years. In 1420 the judges chose his plan, though he had to share the job with Lorenzo Ghiberti, an artist who had beaten him in an earlier contest. The prize money was never paid.

Did you know

The egg story

A famous story says Brunelleschi refused to show his plan. Instead, he challenged his rivals to stand an egg upright on a marble table. When they all failed, he cracked its bottom and stood it up. They protested that anyone could do that. "Yes," he replied, "and you could build the dome too, if I showed you my plan." The best-known version comes from Giorgio Vasari's book about the lives of artists, written in 1550. A mathematician, Luca Pacioli, mentioned the trick around 1500. But both wrote generations later, and no record from Brunelleschi's own time mentions it. It may well be a legend.

Why it mattered

A dome that holds itself up

Brunelleschi built two domes, one inside the other, joined together. This made the structure strong but lighter than one thick dome. In some sections, he laid bricks in a herringbone pattern, a zigzag that locked new bricks in place while the mortar, the wet cement between them, dried. Rings of stone, iron and wood held the dome together like the hoops of a barrel. To lift millions of bricks, he invented a lifting machine turned by oxen. By switching a gear, it could raise or lower loads without the animals having to turn around. Almost 600 years later, it is still the largest brick dome ever built.

The story

Music under the dome

It is 25 March 1436. Under the nearly finished dome, the cathedral is packed for its consecration, a ceremony that dedicates it to God. Pope Eugene IV, who is living in Florence, leads the service. A new piece of music, written for this day by the composer Guillaume Du Fay, fills the space with voices. Above them, the dome rises higher than any building in the city. The last bricks at the top will be laid that August. The lantern, a marble tower about 21 metres tall on its top, will be begun just before Brunelleschi dies in 1446 and finished years later.

Takeaway

The first great Renaissance building

Florence's cathedral had a hole in its roof that nobody knew how to close. Filippo Brunelleschi, a goldsmith inspired by ancient Rome, solved it with two linked shells, herringbone bricks and new machines, and no wooden frame. His dome became a symbol of the Renaissance, the age when Italy looked back to ancient Greece and Rome. Completed in 1436, it is still the largest brick dome ever built. Its story also shows how legends grow: the famous egg trick was first written down long after his death.

Key takeaways

  • ✦The Renaissance, meaning rebirth, was a period from about 1400 when Italian cities looked back to ancient Greece and Rome.
  • ✦Filippo Brunelleschi built Florence's cathedral dome without a wooden frame, using two shells, herringbone bricks and new machines.
  • ✦Completed in 1436, Brunelleschi's dome is still the largest brick dome ever built; the famous egg story is probably a later legend.

Test yourself

Question 1 of 5

What problem did Florence's cathedral builders face in 1418?

Keep going

4 more lessons in The Renaissance, and five other tracks

Answer a few quick questions and get a daily plan built around the history you like, with a quiz after every lesson and a Review mode for the questions you miss.

Build my plan

Plans: $11.07 a month, $19.98 every 3 months or $49.98 a year. Renews automatically until you cancel; cancel anytime in Settings. Prices include VAT where applicable.

Shopping for someone? Give a year of history for $49.98, paid once, no automatic renewal.

Free weekly email

One history myth, busted, every Sunday

A free weekly email: one popular history myth, what really happened, and how we know. Two minutes, every Sunday.